CNN Soledad O’Brien “Special” on being black and male fails to look at the ‘why’
(BALTIMORE – July 27, 2008) – There has been much discussion as of late regarding Soledad O’Brien’s CNN Special about the challenges of being black and male in America. Many agree that she magnificently laid out the problem.
This afternoon, radio journalist David Brown of WEAA 88.9 FM in Baltimore asked me a question regarding what many feel was a sad rendition of the same ol’ song of the drugs, prison and poverty that is so often associated with African American males. He asked me why we – as black men – have this stigma.
I then began to read some of the blogs and commentaries online regarding the CNN series. And one thing I noticed immediately is that people – black people in particular – want to hear more about the successful blacks: The Oprah’s, The Dr. Ben Carson's, and so on and so forth. However, that doesn’t answer David’s question.
So, here’s my take on why black males in America – mostly the descendants of the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade – are the way we are.
I’ll give you two different angles.
From an historical perspective, the black male has been the most ostracized and targeted member of American society – along with the indigenous peoples, a.k.a. the Indians. Now, I don’t play the victim game; let’s get that clear. I know that Africans were just as responsible for us being sold to European and other slave traders.
The issue comes in once our ancestors got on the slave ships. We were introduced to the “n” word. We were essentially broken. I guess Kunta Kinte being made to say “Toby” is a pretty clear example.
I think that once we entered the shores of North America, European Americans did everything humanly possible to degrade, demean, retard, damage, isolate, violate, imprison, and castrate the black male. To them, it was simply an act of war. The goal was to reduce the black man to the level of a four-legged animal.
My dear friend in Chicago, Brother Richard Muhammad – Contributing Editor of The Final Call Newspaper, puts it this way: “The black male has historically been targeted for elimination.” Further, he insists that from the onset, there has been an “assault on the black family.”
BMORENEWS.com Special Correspondent Bobby Marvin puts it another way, all with the same angle: “America was designed to treat the black male with such disregard.” He believes that the CNN Special was “watered-down for white America” and that the white power structure has “failed to take responsibility” in the dilemma of the black male.
My God, when black males were used as studs to breed stronger slaves, when black women were raped by white men in front of their man, when pregnant black women were lynched and had their babies cut out of their wombs in front of mobs of angry white people – you are not going to tell me that black Americans inherently don’t have something locked into our DNA – something deep and dark and ugly. I am not a doctor or a scientist, but common sense says if you have a dog – and beat that dog, and then breed that dog to have more dogs, and beat those dogs, and continue that process for generation after generation after generation – you are not going to tell me that that 5th, 6th, 7th generation dog is going to be as happy and as loving as a dog that comes from generations of loving masters.
In short, as the movie "Claudine" reminds, the black man was never encouraged to be in the home - especially when the welfare worker did their home visits. In fact, I believe it is a wonder the black family even exists.
Again, I don’t play the victim role. I don’t blame anybody. For me, it was simply war. The first object of power, as any good leader knows, is to stay in power. So, for me, there is no wonder why blacks lead in just about every negative socio-economic category out there: AIDS and HIV, prison, under-education, underperforming businesses, broken marriages and homes. The answer is very clear to me.
David Brown also said to me that there was a time when we, black people, “were a proud people. We were a praying people.”
And that leads to my second angle on the whole Soledad O’Brien CNN Special.
We were once proud and loving, David! You are right! And, if I am not mistaken, that was last most visibly evident in the 60’s. Black Power was the order of the day. Black Panthers were amongst our grassroots leadership. Malcolm X was speaking truth to power. And Martin Luther King, Jr. was rocking the world with his incredible oratories.
And then came the government.
I was most reminded of the effects of the ‘60’s during a 2006 trip to Tanzania where I sat with Pete O’Neal. The former Black Panther has being living in exile for nearly four decades.
Other heroes and sheroes come to mind like Angela Davis and Assata Shakur.
One by one, our pride and our love was replaced with heroine, cocaine, and assassins’ bullets. Piece by piece, this government did everything possible and necessary to quell the native uprising such that what happened in Haiti under the leadership of Toussant L’Overture would never happen in America. White America realized that people like Denmark Vesey and Nat Turner and Gabriel Prosser and Harriet Tubman were a serious threat to the maintenance of their power.
Understand, what happened to blacks in America was also attempted on blacks in Jamaica and Brazil and everywhere blacks were sold as slaves. And back on the continent, as outlined by author Chinua Achebe, a similar annihilation was underway, a.k.a. colonialism. Every country in Africa – with the exception of a two-year occupation of Ethiopia by the Italians – was colonized and then neo-colonized. European powers split-up the continent like a pizza with the British over here and the French over there and Belgians down there and the Dutch all the way down there. Several European countries – and the USA – owe their wealth, in my best estimation, to either the free black labor or the natural resources and minerals stolen – yes, stolen – from Africa.
So, here’s the hit to my second point. Black men, black women, black families: We have to go back to our spiritual roots. We have to be obedient. If one is Muslim, get back to the dien (the faith). If one is Christian, go back to church. Faith and prayer is the only solution to the madness of this world. And, truth be told, while whites have typically been the oppressor, I believe the real oppressor is evil. And evil is colorless.
That’s my take. No disrespect to anyone.
One final thought: Black people must learn history from a black perspective. And that means that the Black Diaspora needs its own independent media – like www.BMORENEWS.com. For when others tell our story (Wendell Phillips said similar words to Frederick Douglass, "Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass"), the picture gets distorted. A classic example of this happened during my 2002 trip to Jordan with the late, great Arthur Murphy. There I learned that the Jordanians I met knew nothing about Malcolm or Martin or Rosa or Harriet. They only knew about hip hop videos.
‘Til next time, be well. Even more, take your children to the library and read some books by people like Frantz Fanon, W.E.B. DuBois, and Malcolm X.
Read more from BMORENEWS.COM
Op/Ed: Journalist Extraordinaire McCarthy Still Fasting for I Can't We Can:
I opened my hand and he poured $4 in quarters into my palm. "That's all I got right now," he said.
I stood there in amazement. So many people are struggling and having such a hard time. But they get it. They seem to understand that some things are worth giving all you have.
Read in Full >>The Glover Report: Family, Schools and Churches:
Even more, his presentation before Associated Black Charities of Maryland at the Reginald F. Lewis Museum on Wednesday afternoon went into what he believes are the three major anchors of the black community that must be re-engaged such that black America can be all that it is supposed to be. After all, with the election of President-elect Barack Obama, this is supposed to represent a new beginning. Read in Full >>
Meeting Morehouse College President Franklin Was An Inspirational Experience:
He, in fact, is a reminder – with all due respect to all of the black schools out there – why I first chose – at the urging of my high school counselors - to attend Morehouse. It was a vivid reminder of the three semesters I was blessed to be at – in my mind – the greatest institution on the planet with some of the greatest minds I have ever known. Morehouse students like Adam Scott, Leo Hyman and Robbie Scott from Baltimore and Steven Tolbert, the son of a Liberian president, come to mind. Read in Full >>
Op/Ed: Give Thanks and Praise: Reframing Recession into Abundance:
As we gain perspective and reaffirm our faith, obstacles in our path start to seem less obstructive and more instructive. Instead of complaining about our empty gas tanks, we begin to appreciate the benefits of walking, biking or taking the bus to work. After all, most of us could stand to become a bit more physically fit. Walking to work provides us with such an opportunity. Similarly, taking the bus may relieve the stress of navigating morning traffic jams, and give us time to plan our day more effectively. Read in Full >>
Op/Ed: The Reckoning of the Uninvited:
Where had these people been before? Looking at those now around me, I thought how much past voting had been a closed affair. How much had we come to expect that certain people would just not show up on Election Day – to the point that some politicians even counted on it? Had our democracy really offered an “open” invitation some people simply weren’t supposed to accept? Read in Full >>





What do you think?
3 comment(s) on this page. Add your own comment below.
Help us make our ten million dollar + mark! We cannot do it without your support.
If you would like to show your support; in words or financial giving, please contact:
Son Lets Renovate at:
Son Let's Renovate c/o E. Craig Jackson
P.O. Box 13236
Philadelphia, PA 19101
ecsogreat@yahoo.com
(267) 312-4161
Donations are generously accepted…
Soledad O’Brien, Hi my name is Chris Peart I'm a born Jamaican. I watched your show regarding "Black in America". I wasn’t too happy how the show portrait blacks people in a America, because we have more Black men and women in society that are doing wonderful, but we don't showcase that, because it would show up America to show how blacks are doing well. Why can’t we have a show on the positive black people that are doing fine in society, and that might up lift the ones who are in poverty? Because they would see that if my brothers and sisters are lawyers, doctors, judges, CEO’s they might think they might have a chance to be somebody positive in society, but no, we always want to have forums on the negative side of black people rather than the positive side. Look what's happen in the NFL, since Doug Williams won the Super Bowl for the Washington Redskins. We have had so much black quarterbacks in the NFL for example, Mike Vick, Vince Young, Donovan McNabb, Steve McNair and many others. So if we didn't see that Doug played as a quarterback, blacks would have think it's only white guys only that’s allowed to played that position, but no, we put an end to that. Now, we as black people need to show more of the positive side of us so that the negative side can sit and watch and say "I didn't know that", because most of our brothers and sisters don't get to see the positive side of us, because the media is not showing that side of us they rather show Pokie stealing from the Farm Store that’ around the corner, and make our younger generation think it’s a normal thing in our community. So good show, but let do more on the positive of our people, so the negative side can start changing their minds, because if we show more positive, the negative might one day decide it's I want to be somebody in life.
So, please showcase the positive side of us for and change.
Thank you and God Bless...
SOLEDAD O'BRIEN'S SPECIAL WAS JUST THAT, "HER OWN STORY." THIS DOCUMENTARY IN NO WAY TOUCHED THE TRUTH OF THE MATTER. I AM A 67 YEARS OLD BLACK FEMALE AND WAS QUITE DISGUSTED WITH HER DOCUMENTARY. IT IN NO WAY RELFECTED ANYTHING PERTAINING TO "BLACKS IN AMERICA." HAVE YOU WONDERED IF SHE WAS TRYING TO FIND HERSELF? IT TURNED OUT TO BE TOTALLY RIDICULOUS. IN NO WAY DID HER STORY EVEN PUT A DENT IN BEING BLACK IN AMERICA.
Add a Comment
Please be civil.